Therapy and Coaching: How to Handle Clients Who Want Both

Table of Contents

• Therapy and Coaching: How to Handle Clients Who Want Both
• Understanding the Difference Between Therapy and Coaching
• Why Some Clients Want Both Services
• Potential Pitfalls of Combining Therapy and Coaching
• Best Practices for Handling Clients Who Want Both
  • 1. Be Explicit from the Outset
  • 2. Keep Services Separate
  • 3. Use Distinct Service Agreements
  • 4. Document Separately
  • 5. Stay Within Your Scope
• Example Scenarios
  • Scenario 1: Coaching First, Then Therapy
  • Scenario 2: Therapy to Manage Anxiety, Then Coaching for Goal-Setting
• The Referral Mindset
• Protecting Yourself and Serving Clients Best
• Conclusion: Clarity Is Crucial
• FAQs

Therapy and Coaching: How to Handle Clients Who Want Both

Therapy and Coaching: How to Handle Clients Who Want Both

Balancing the roles of providing therapy and being a coach can be an exhilarating yet challenging pursuit. As these two fields continue to evolve and intersect, it’s becoming more common for clients to request therapy and coaching—sometimes simultaneously. Therapists who also offer coaching frequently find themselves fielding the question: “Can you work with me on personal development goals while also providing clinical support for my mental health concerns?”

This scenario can be tricky. On the one hand, your client may appreciate your expertise in both areas, believing it will save them time, money, or the hassle of working with multiple professionals. On the other hand, combining therapy and coaching for the same individual in the same timeframe can cause confusion about roles, confidentiality, and boundaries. In some cases, it can even blur the lines between clinical treatment and personal development in a way that raises ethical red flags.

This blog post will explore the benefits, risks, and best practices in handling clients who want therapy and coaching. By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of how to structure your services, communicate boundaries, and ensure the client’s best interests remain at the forefront while protecting yourself legally and ethically.

Understanding the Difference Between Therapy and Coaching

To navigate this dual role of therapy and coaching effectively, it’s important to remember the core distinctions between therapy and coaching:

1. Therapy:

   • A regulated clinical service focusing on diagnosing and treating mental health conditions.
   • Often involves exploring past traumas, persistent emotional struggles, and mental health symptoms.
   • Typically requires licensure and adherence to strict legal and ethical guidelines.
   • Often billed through insurance, requiring a formal diagnosis and medical necessity.

2. Coaching:

   • Unregulated and future-focused, emphasizing goal attainment, personal development, and accountability.
   • Typically does not explore in-depth childhood trauma or provide clinical diagnoses for mental health disorders.
   • Not usually covered by insurance, relying instead on private pay.
   • Concentrates on actionable steps and measurable outcomes.

While therapy and coaching aim to help individuals grow and overcome barriers, their methods, legal frameworks, and scope differ. Inadvertently Crossing these boundaries can lead to ethical dilemmas or potential liability issues.

Why Some Clients Want Both Services

Clients may express a desire for both therapy and coaching for several reasons:

• Holistic Support: They might see the need for deep emotional work around issues like anxiety or depression while also wanting guidance on specific life goals or career transitions.
• Time and Convenience: Instead of working with one professional for mental health concerns and another for goal-based coaching, they’d turn to a single, trusted individual who understands their entire situation.
• Belief in Faster Results: Some clients assume having one “dual expert” will streamline their progress.
• Familiarity and Trust: If they’ve already built rapport with you in a therapeutic context, they might prefer you as their coach for consistency and comfort.

While these motivations are understandable, it’s critical to remember that therapy and coaching require different skill sets, professional boundaries, and documentation procedures. Mixing the two without a strategy can lead to role confusion for you and your client.

Potential Pitfalls of Combining Therapy and Coaching

Despite client enthusiasm, offering both services simultaneously to the same individual can pose significant challenges:

1. Role Confusion
   The biggest concern is that it’s not always clear when you’re acting as a therapist and when you’re acting as a coach. The client may expect therapeutic support for situations you intend to address solely through a coaching lens.

2. Ethical and Legal Risks
   You are bound by state regulations and ethical codes as a licensed therapist. Providing therapy to clients outside your licensing jurisdiction or coaching them in a way that morphs into treatment can lead to inquiries from your licensing board. Therefore, it becomes essential to document your work accurately and maintain proper clinical boundaries.

3. Mixed Goals and Objectives
   Therapy often focuses on alleviating symptoms, healing past traumas, and fostering emotional well-being. Coaching zeroes in on actionable steps and future planning. If a client tries to achieve both simultaneously, sessions can become disjointed, making measuring progress in either realm difficult.

4. Confidentiality and Documentation
   Therapy records must meet specific legal standards, especially if you bill insurance. Coaching documentation, by contrast, is more flexible. Mixing records may inadvertently violate privacy regulations or pose complications if an insurance company requests documentation.

5. Client Dependency
   There’s a risk that clients become overly reliant on you for both clinical support and personal development. Without clear boundaries, this dual reliance may stifle self-agency, as they look to one person for nearly all emotional and personal growth aspects.

Best Practices for Handling Clients Who Want Both

If a client approaches you seeking therapy and coaching, please take a look at the following guidelines to maintain clarity and professional standards.

1. Be Explicit from the Outset

Your initial conversation or consultation should clarify whether the relationship falls under therapy or coaching. Ask open-ended questions to gauge what kind of help they’re genuinely seeking:

• Are they dealing with diagnosed mental health conditions?
• Do they want to process unresolved trauma or persistent emotional pain?
• Are they primarily focused on life or career goals, strategizing next steps, and seeking accountability?

Point out that therapy and coaching are fundamentally different, explaining that while you are qualified to offer both services, you typically won’t combine them for the same client simultaneously. This transparency sets expectations early on.

2. Keep Services Separate

If you provide services to the same individual, avoid doing so simultaneously on the same issues. One recommended approach is:

• Therapeutic Work First: If a client exhibits clinical concerns—such as significant depression, anxiety, or trauma— address those through therapy.
• Transition to Coaching: After the therapeutic goals are met and the client’s mental health is stable, you can transition them into a coaching relationship. Make sure to close the therapeutic relationship officially and document the change.

Alternatively, could you refer the client to another therapist if you think a different professional setting or modality will serve them better, then proceed with coaching if and when they reach a point where clinical issues no longer require ongoing therapeutic intervention?

3. Use Distinct Service Agreements

Provide separate contracts or agreements for therapy and coaching. This means:

• A therapy consent form that outlines the mental health support you’ll provide, the limits of confidentiality, and how billing or insurance claims will work.
• A coaching contract that clarifies the goal-oriented nature of the service, the private-pay structure, and the absence of any formal mental health diagnosis or treatment.

Could you encourage clients to read both documents carefully? Having them sign these agreements cements the understanding that each service has distinct aims and boundaries.

4. Document Separately

Always maintain separate records for therapy and coaching. Mixing notes in one client file can cause confusion—especially if insurance, licensing boards, or other entities request documentation.

• Therapy Notes: Should follow your state guidelines and reflect clinical justifications, progress notes, and any treatment plans.
• Coaching Notes Can be more flexible and objective-focused. They outline goals, action steps, and accountability checkpoints.

Such separation demonstrates professional integrity and clarity of service should questions ever arise.

5. Stay Within Your Scope

Even if you’re licensed as a therapist, it doesn’t mean you can practice therapy with a client living in a state where you don’t hold licensure. The same caution applies to coaching that inadvertently crosses over into therapeutic territory. If, during coaching sessions, deeper mental health issues surface, refer the client back to therapy with a provider licensed in their jurisdiction, even if that provider is you—provided you’re licensed to practice in that location and follow the proper intake and documentation for therapy.

Example Scenarios

Let’s look at a couple of hypothetical examples:

Scenario 1: Coaching First, Then Therapy

A client from out of state hires you as a coach to help plan a career transition. After several sessions, they reveal a history of severe trauma that they feel is preventing them from moving forward. Because they’re showing signs of unresolved PTSD, you realize they need clinical intervention. You refer them to a local therapist since you aren’t licensed in their state. Once they complete therapy or reach stability, you might resume coaching if you and the client decide it’s beneficial.

Scenario 2: Therapy to Manage Anxiety, Then Coaching for Goal-Setting

Another client resides in a state where you’re licensed. They have generalized anxiety disorder and want both therapy and help outlining future goals. Start by addressing their anxiety clinically through regular treatment. When their symptoms are under control, and they’re no longer meeting diagnostic criteria for significant anxiety, formally close out the therapy case. Next, sign a coaching contract and shift the focus to goal attainment—ensuring they know it’s no longer a clinical relationship but a partnership aimed at personal development.

In both scenarios, you’re clear about transitions, documentation, and the nature of each service. This helps protect your license, maintain ethical boundaries, and provide the highest quality of care.

The Referral Mindset

Maintaining a strong network of fellow therapists and coaches you can trust is a helpful practice. If a pure coaching client presents clinical mental health concerns, you’ll have resources to refer them. Likewise, if a therapy client finishes treatment but wants specialized coaching beyond your scope—perhaps for executive leadership or elite athletic performance—you can refer them to a coach with that specialty.

Embracing referrals benefits everyone involved. Clients receive the precise support they need, and you avoid overextending your professional boundaries or practicing outside your zone of expertise. It also strengthens your professional credibility and fosters reciprocal referrals.

Protecting Yourself and Serving Clients Best

By keeping your roles clear, you protect your professional license and your reputation. You also safeguard the client’s well-being and ensure they get the most appropriate services at any given time. Here are a few parting tips:

1. Ongoing Education: Stay updated on your state’s licensing regulations for therapy and coaching guidelines from reputable organizations (such as the International Coaching Federation).
2. Legal Counsel: If you’re unsure about the legalities of offering both services, consult an attorney familiar with mental health and coaching regulations.
3. Supervision or Mentorship: Connecting with supervisors or more experienced professionals can offer insights and guidance on ethically navigating these dual roles.
4. Transparent Communication: Remind your client and yourself of the boundaries and distinctions between therapy and coaching. Periodically reassess whether one is best for the client.
5. Self-Care: Balancing therapy and coaching can be mentally and emotionally demanding. Practice self-care to prevent burnout and bring your best self to each client interaction.

Conclusion: Clarity Is Crucial

When clients want therapy and coaching, the best approach is to be explicit about which service applies to which issues. While it may be tempting to blur the lines for convenience, combining therapy and coaching simultaneously can create confusion, ethical dilemmas, and potential legal pitfalls. If a coaching client develops mental health concerns that require clinical intervention, refer them to therapy—whether that’s through you in a separate, adequately documented arrangement (and only if you’re licensed in their state) or another qualified professional. Once those concerns are appropriately managed, you can return to a goal-focused coaching framework if it still serves them.

Ultimately, the key is maintaining clarity around the roles of therapy and coaching, boundaries, and documentation. By doing so, you preserve the integrity of your therapeutic and coaching services while offering clients the specialized support they truly need. As these fields continue to overlap, handling clients who want both services responsibly is not just an ethical responsibility—it’s a hallmark of excellence that ensures positive, lasting outcomes.

If you want to join a growing community of Christian Life Coaches and learners from a Licensed Therapist and Certified Life Coach, click HERE to learn more!